AutoStore vs Kiva Systems (Amazon Robotics)

When it comes to warehouse automation, there are several systems available in the market. Two of the most popular ones are AutoStore and Kiva Systems, which is now known as Amazon Robotics. In this article, we will explore the working mechanism, features, and cost-effectiveness of both systems in detail. We will also analyze the impact of these systems on warehouse automation and future trends. Lastly, we will discuss how you can choose between these systems and the pros and cons of using each one.

A Brief Introduction to AutoStore and Kiva Systems

AutoStore and Kiva Systems are two of the most popular warehouse automation systems in the market that use robots to move goods around the warehouse. Both systems are designed to increase efficiency and productivity while reducing labor costs. However, they differ in terms of their working mechanism, features, and price. Let’s take a closer look at how these systems work.

AutoStore is a cube-based system that uses small robots to move bins of products around the warehouse. The robots move on top of a grid of cubes, which are stacked on top of each other to create a dense storage system. The robots pick up the bins and move them to a workstation where a human worker can pick the products and fulfill orders. AutoStore is known for its high storage density and flexibility, as it can be easily reconfigured to accommodate changing inventory needs.

Kiva Systems, on the other hand, uses mobile robots to move entire shelves of products around the warehouse. The robots are guided by a central control system that directs them to the appropriate shelf and location. When an order is received, the robots bring the entire shelf to a workstation where a human worker can pick the products and fulfill the order. Kiva Systems is known for its speed and scalability, as it can handle large volumes of orders and can be easily expanded to accommodate growing businesses.

Understanding the Working Mechanism of AutoStore

AutoStore is an automated storage and retrieval system that uses an integrated grid of bins, robots, and software to efficiently manage inventory within a warehouse. The system is comprised of compact boxes stacked on top of each other and arranged like a honeycomb, with robots moving through the empty spaces to retrieve or store items. Each bin can hold a maximum weight of 77 lbs. AutoStore’s robots move along the top of the stacks and utilize a lifting beam to access the bins. The system uses sophisticated software to ensure maximum efficiency by optimizing the robot movements.

One of the key advantages of AutoStore is its ability to adapt to changing inventory needs. The system can be easily reconfigured to accommodate new products or changes in demand, without requiring major modifications to the warehouse layout. This flexibility allows businesses to quickly respond to market trends and customer needs, while minimizing downtime and disruption to operations. Additionally, AutoStore’s compact design and high storage density make it an ideal solution for warehouses with limited space, as it can store up to four times more inventory than traditional shelving systems.

Understanding the Working Mechanism of Kiva Systems

Kiva Systems, on the other hand, uses a fleet of mobile robots that work to bring the items to humans in the warehouse. The robots are small, self-guided vehicles that move under a product shelf, lift it, and move it to a picking station. By using a central computer system, Kiva robots work in tandem to transport goods to humans who then pick the respective items. The robots move seamlessly and do not require any rails or tracks on the floor. Because the robots are self-contained, they can accommodate changing configurations in the warehouse.

One of the key advantages of Kiva Systems is that it can significantly reduce the time it takes to fulfill orders. With the use of robots, the system can quickly and efficiently move products from one location to another, reducing the time it takes for workers to locate and retrieve items manually. This can lead to faster order processing times and increased customer satisfaction.

Another benefit of Kiva Systems is that it can help reduce the risk of workplace injuries. By automating the process of moving heavy products, workers are less likely to suffer from back injuries or other physical strains. Additionally, the robots themselves are designed to operate safely in a warehouse environment, reducing the risk of accidents or injuries caused by human error.

The Features That Make AutoStore Stand Out from Kiva Systems

AutoStore’s key advantage over Kiva Systems is its exceptional storage density. The compact grid design allows a large amount of inventory to be stored in a small space. As a result, AutoStore can provide four times the storage capacity in the same space, compared to Kiva Systems. The system can also operate in a variety of temperature and humidity conditions with no impact on its efficiency. In addition, robots in AutoStore can efficiently access bins from the top, enabling a high pick rate.

Another advantage of AutoStore is its flexibility in terms of layout and configuration. The system can be easily adapted to fit the specific needs of a warehouse or distribution center, allowing for efficient use of space and resources. Additionally, AutoStore’s robots are designed to work collaboratively, allowing for seamless coordination and optimization of tasks.

AutoStore also offers advanced software and analytics capabilities, providing real-time data on inventory levels, order fulfillment, and system performance. This allows for proactive maintenance and optimization, reducing downtime and improving overall efficiency. Furthermore, AutoStore’s software can integrate with existing warehouse management systems, streamlining operations and improving accuracy.

The Features That Make Kiva Systems Stand Out from AutoStore

One of the chief advantages that Kiva Systems has is its flexibility. The system can accommodate frequent changes to the product mix and fit a wide range of products, from shoes to heavy-duty tools. Kiva robots can move up to five tons of weight, making them well-suited for bulk orders and shipments. Another significant advantage is that Kiva systems require less initial capital investment than AutoStore. Moreover, the operations team does not need special training to navigate robot movements, increasing convenience and ease of use.

Another feature that sets Kiva Systems apart from AutoStore is its ability to integrate with existing warehouse management systems. This means that businesses can easily incorporate Kiva robots into their current operations without having to overhaul their entire system. Additionally, Kiva robots are designed to work collaboratively with human workers, allowing for a more efficient and productive workflow.

Furthermore, Kiva Systems offers a high level of customization to meet the specific needs of each business. The system can be tailored to fit the layout and size of the warehouse, as well as the unique requirements of the products being stored and shipped. This level of customization ensures that businesses can optimize their operations and maximize their productivity.

A Comparative Analysis of the Two Systems

When it comes to a fair comparison, both systems have their own advantages and drawbacks. AutoStore is exceptional in terms of storage density, and its robots can access bins from the top, which makes item retrieval more efficient. In contrast, Kiva Systems is highly flexible and can accommodate changes in product handling requirements. The system is also cost-effective, given that the robots require less initial capital to install. Another significant difference is that AutoStore robots require a separate workstation to pick items, whereas Kiva robots bring items to a single picking station.

Which System is More Cost-Effective?

One of the key factors that businesses must consider when choosing between AutoStore and Kiva Systems is the cost-effectiveness of each system. While both systems are designed to reduce labor costs associated with manual handling of goods, Kiva is generally the more cost-effective solution. Kiva Systems require less capital investment, is less maintenance-intensive and is more energy-efficient. However, AutoStore’s higher storage density can reduce the warehouse footprint.

Which System is More Efficient?

Efficiency-wise, both systems have their own pros and cons. AutoStore offers high storage density, high pick rates, and efficient inventory control, making it well-suited for businesses that handle a large volume of smaller items. Kiva Systems, on the other hand, is highly flexible, requiring less time for configuration changes. The robots are easily moved and reconfigured to accommodate different shelves and item types. It also works well when items are only ever carried in pallets.

The Impact of AutoStore and Kiva Systems on Warehouse Automation

Warehouses that have implemented AutoStore or Kiva Systems have experienced increased efficiency, reduced labor costs, and improved accuracy. Both systems work to reduce manual labor and increase speed, making them essential tools of the Fourth Industrial Revolution. Additionally, automation technology is expected to reduce the need for traditional storage processes like racks, shelves, and bins. Systems like AutoStore and Kiva will help businesses to deliver products efficiently and seamlessly.

Future Trends in Warehouse Automation with Respect to These Systems

The trend of warehouse automation is expected to continue in the coming years. Technological advancements, increasing demand for fast delivery, and the need to cut down on production costs will likely drive the uptake of warehouse automation solutions globally. The competition between AutoStore and Kiva Systems is projected to increase, with each system being upgraded to improve efficiency continuously. Moreover, integrating other technologies like Big Data and the Internet of Things will lead to the development of more advanced warehouse automation systems.

Case Studies of Companies Using AutoStore and Kiva Systems

Many companies have already adopted AutoStore and Kiva Systems in their warehouses with great success. AutoStore’s clients range from electronics retailers like Fry’s Electronics, to online mega-retailer Zalando and pharmaceutical giant Boehringer Ingelheim. Similarly, companies like The Gap, Staples, and Crate & Barrel have implemented Kiva robots to boost their warehouse capacity.

How to Choose Between AutoStore and Kiva Systems for Your Business

The best way to choose between AutoStore and Kiva Systems for your business is to compare the efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and flexibility of each system. Businesses that handle smaller products with higher rotation rates may find AutoStore to be a more viable option, while businesses that handle larger products and require more flexible systems might find Kiva a better fit for their operations. To make an informed decision, businesses should evaluate their warehousing needs and consult with experts offering warehouse automation services.

Pros and Cons of Using Each System

To summarize, AutoStore offers high storage density, exceptional efficiency, and is well-suited for businesses that prioritize high-rotation smaller goods. Kiva Systems, on the other hand, offers flexibility, reduced initial capital requirements, and is well-suited for businesses handling bulkier goods. However, the deciding factor comes down to specific requirements, as well as the cost and ROI for each specific business.

Conclusion: Which System is the Best Fit for Your Business?

It is no secret that both AutoStore and Kiva Systems have revolutionized warehouse automation. These two systems offer unique advantages, making them highly relevant options for all businesses that operate in warehousing. To choose between the two, it is essential to evaluate your warehouse need and select the system that best suits your operational requirements. Automating warehouse operations through AutoStore and Kiva Systems will increase efficiency, provide better accuracy, and simultaneously reduce human error, making them a must-have addition to any future-focused business.

Rate this article:
Share it:

Join hundreds of smart shippers. Guaranteed to save.