eBay vs BigCommerce

May 8, 2023
Written by
Anthony Robinson
eBay vs BigCommerce

Introduction to eBay and BigCommerce

In the competitive landscape of online selling, eBay and BigCommerce emerge as prominent platforms, each catering to different business needs. eBay, a well-established online marketplace, connects sellers with a vast global audience. In contrast, BigCommerce offers a robust e-commerce solution for businesses aiming to build and manage their own online stores. This comprehensive comparison explores the strengths and weaknesses of both platforms to help you determine which aligns best with your business objectives.

History and Growth of eBay and BigCommerce

eBay: A Pioneer in Online Marketplaces

Founded in 1995 by Pierre Omidyar, eBay revolutionized online commerce by introducing an auction-based model that allowed individuals and businesses to buy and sell a wide array of products globally. By 2023, eBay boasts over 182 million active buyers, solidifying its position as a leading online marketplace.

BigCommerce: Empowering Independent Businesses

Established in 2009 by Eddie Machaalani and Mitchell Harper, BigCommerce was created to provide businesses with the tools necessary to create scalable and customizable online stores. Serving over 60,000 merchants across more than 150 countries, BigCommerce has become a preferred platform for businesses seeking flexibility and growth opportunities.

Feature Comparison

Ease of Use

eBay offers a user-friendly interface with straightforward listing processes, making it accessible for sellers new to online marketplaces. BigCommerce, while slightly more complex, provides extensive customization options and a range of built-in features that cater to businesses seeking a tailored shopping experience.

Payment Options

Both platforms support multiple payment methods. eBay integrates seamlessly with PayPal, credit cards, and other payment gateways. BigCommerce expands on this by supporting over 60 payment gateways, including Stripe and Square, and offers multi-currency support to facilitate international transactions.

Fees Structure

eBay operates on a fee-based model, charging for listings and taking a percentage of each sale. These fees can accumulate, especially for high-volume sellers. Conversely, BigCommerce charges a monthly subscription fee, which varies based on the plan selected. This model can be more cost-effective for businesses with steady sales volumes, eliminating per-sale fees.

Customer Support

eBay provides a variety of support resources, including help centers and community forums. BigCommerce stands out with its 24/7 customer support via phone, email, and live chat, alongside a comprehensive knowledge base, ensuring businesses receive timely assistance when needed.

Integrations

Integration capabilities are crucial for streamlined operations. eBay allows integration with popular shipping and inventory management tools, as well as social media platforms. BigCommerce offers a broader range of integrations, including accounting software like QuickBooks, email marketing tools like Mailchimp, and various CRM systems.

Pros and Cons

Selling on eBay

Advantages:

  • Access to a massive user base, enhancing product visibility
  • Diverse listing options, including auction and fixed-price
  • Integrated seller tools for optimizing listings
  • Simple setup with a user-friendly interface
  • Multiple payment options through PayPal and others

Disadvantages:

  • High competition can make it challenging to stand out
  • Listing and final value fees can reduce profit margins
  • Potential risk of fraud despite security measures
  • Limited customization for store design and functionality

Selling on BigCommerce

Advantages:

  • Extensive customization with customizable templates and built-in marketing tools
  • Highly scalable, supporting business growth effectively
  • Unlimited product listings without additional fees
  • Supports multiple currencies, appealing to international customers
  • Wide range of payment gateways enhances payment flexibility

Disadvantages:

  • Requires a certain level of technical expertise for setup and management
  • Ongoing monthly subscription fees can be a barrier for startups

Choosing the Right Platform for Your Business

Selecting between eBay and BigCommerce hinges on factors such as business size, product range, customization needs, and technical capabilities. Businesses seeking a straightforward platform with immediate access to a large audience may find eBay more suitable. In contrast, those aiming for a customized brand presence with scalable features might prefer BigCommerce.

Success Stories

eBay Success Stories

Numerous small businesses have leveraged eBay’s extensive reach to scale operations significantly. For instance, Forbes highlights several sellers who started on eBay and expanded into multi-channel retailing, attributing their growth to the platform’s diverse customer base.

BigCommerce Success Stories

BigCommerce has been instrumental in the success of various brands. A notable example is Gymshark, a fitness apparel company that utilized BigCommerce's scalable infrastructure to support rapid growth and international expansion, enhancing their online presence and sales.

Future Outlook

Both eBay and BigCommerce are poised for continued growth in the evolving e-commerce landscape. eBay is focusing on enhancing user experience and expanding its global marketplace features. Meanwhile, BigCommerce is investing in advanced technologies like artificial intelligence and machine learning to provide more personalized shopping experiences and robust analytics for businesses. These strategic developments aim to meet the dynamic needs of consumers and sellers alike.

Optimizing Your Sales on eBay or BigCommerce

  • Optimize Product Listings: Use relevant keywords and detailed descriptions to improve search engine rankings. Incorporate high-quality images and clear product information.
  • Leverage Social Media: Promote your products on platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter to drive traffic to your store.
  • Monitor and Analyze Performance: Utilize analytics tools to track sales metrics and customer behavior, allowing for data-driven adjustments to your sales strategy.
  • Enhance Customer Experience: Provide exceptional customer service, fast shipping, and easy returns to build trust and encourage repeat business.

Conclusion

Choosing between eBay and BigCommerce depends on your business model, goals, and resources. eBay offers a straightforward platform with immediate access to a vast audience, ideal for businesses looking to quickly enter the market. BigCommerce provides a more customizable and scalable solution, suitable for businesses aiming to establish a strong, independent online presence. By carefully evaluating your business needs and leveraging the strengths of each platform, you can effectively grow your online operations and achieve sustained success.

About the Author

Anthony Robinson is the CEO of ShipScience, a pioneering company dedicated to helping e-commerce leaders optimize their shipping decisions, reduce costs, and automate tedious processes. With a Bachelors Degree in Economics from Stanford University, Anthony brings over two decades of expertise in logistics, business development, and operational efficiency to the table.
Read More
Revolutionize your parcel shipping strategy.
Get a free analysis
© Copyright 2024 ShipScience.com. All Rights Reserved.  Terms of Use  |  Privacy
All other trademarks and copyrights are the property of their respective owners.