Honeywell Voyager 1200g vs Symbol LS2208 by Zebra
If you're in the market for a new barcode scanner, two popular options are the Honeywell Voyager 1200g and the Symbol LS2208 by Zebra. Both scanners offer unique features and benefits, making it essential to understand their differences before making a decision. This article provides an in-depth comparison of these two scanners, covering aspects such as design, performance, durability, pricing, and user reviews. By the end, you'll have a clear idea of which scanner best fits your business needs.
Introduction to Honeywell Voyager 1200g and Symbol LS2208
The Honeywell Voyager 1200g and the Symbol LS2208 scanner by Zebra are among the most popular barcode scanners available today. Designed to efficiently capture data from barcodes, both scanners transmit information to computers or mobile devices seamlessly. Honeywell, a leader in automatic identification and data capture solutions, manufactures the Voyager 1200g, while Zebra Technologies, a renowned name in the barcode scanning industry, produces the Symbol LS2208.
While both scanners excel in data capture, they cater to different business needs. The Voyager 1200g boasts a higher scanning speed and longer read distance, making it suitable for high-volume environments. In contrast, the Symbol LS2208 is more compact and lightweight, ideal for businesses requiring portability and ease of handling.
Both scanners are compatible with various operating systems and can be easily integrated into existing systems. Built to endure harsh conditions, they are drop-resistant and durable, ensuring longevity even in demanding settings. Overall, the Honeywell Voyager 1200g and the Symbol LS2208 by Zebra are reliable tools for businesses aiming to enhance their barcode scanning processes.
Key Features
Honeywell Voyager 1200g
- Advanced Scanning Technology: Capable of reading virtually any barcode type, including 1D, 2D, and QR codes.
- Automatic Interface Detection: Automatically detects the type of interface used by connected devices, simplifying setup and configuration.
- Durable Design: Features drop-resistant housing that can withstand falls from up to 1.5 meters, making it ideal for warehouses and manufacturing facilities.
- High-Performance Scanning Engine: Can capture barcodes from up to 58 cm away, allowing scanning without close proximity.
- Long Battery Life: Provides extended usage between charges, reducing downtime in busy environments.
The Honeywell Voyager 1200g integrates cutting-edge technology to ensure swift and accurate barcode reads. Its ergonomic design offers a comfortable grip, reducing user fatigue during extended scanning sessions. Additionally, its robust build quality ensures it can withstand the rigors of daily industrial use.
Symbol LS2208 by Zebra
- Lightweight and Ergonomic: Designed for ease of use with a comfortable hold, suitable for prolonged use.
- Versatile Scanning Capabilities: Reads both 1D and 2D barcodes, making it adaptable for various scanning needs.
- Wide Scan Angle: Capable of reading barcodes from a distance, enhancing efficiency in high-volume scanning operations.
- Multi-Platform Compatibility: Compatible with Windows, Mac, and Linux operating systems without the need for additional drivers.
- Affordable Pricing: Offers a cost-effective solution without compromising on essential features.
The Symbol LS2208 is celebrated for its balance of performance and affordability. Its compact and lightweight design makes it a favorite among retailers and small businesses that require reliable yet portable scanning solutions.
Performance Analysis
Both scanners are lauded for their high performance, but they differ in specific areas:
- Scan Rate: The Honeywell Voyager 1200g offers up to 100 scans per second, matching the Symbol LS2208's maximum scan speed.
- Accuracy: The Voyager 1200g features a higher resolution sensor, enhancing its ability to read damaged or low-contrast barcodes more accurately.
- Durability: The Voyager 1200g withstands drops from 1.5 meters, compared to the LS2208's 1.2-meter drop resistance, making it more suitable for rugged environments.
In performance benchmarks, the Voyager 1200g tends to excel in environments requiring rapid and precise scanning, while the Symbol LS2208 provides reliable performance for standard scanning tasks.
Design and Ergonomics
Design Comparison
Design plays a crucial role in user experience and functionality:
- Honeywell Voyager 1200g:
- Sleek and modern aesthetic with a robust build.
- Includes a stand for surface mounting.
- Bright LED aimer for clear targeting.
- Symbol LS2208:
- Ergonomic and compact design for comfortable handling.
- Comes with a hands-free stand for efficient scanning without manual interference.
- Laser aimer for precise scanning of small or intricate barcodes.
The Voyager 1200g's ability to read barcodes from a greater distance is advantageous for scanning items on high shelves. Meanwhile, the LS2208's wider scanning range ensures versatility in various scanning environments. Both scanners incorporate durable designs to withstand drops and impacts, but their ergonomic features cater to different user preferences.
Ergonomics Comparison
Ergonomics are vital for reducing user fatigue and increasing productivity:
- Honeywell Voyager 1200g:
- Enhanced grip design for comfortable handling.
- Slightly larger grip accommodates users with larger hands.
- Symbol LS2208:
- Lightweight construction reduces strain during prolonged use.
- Compact design facilitates maneuvering in tight spaces.
Both scanners are designed for extended use without causing discomfort. The Voyager 1200g's ergonomic grip is beneficial for users requiring a sturdy hold, while the LS2208's lightweight and compact form factor cater to those needing flexibility and ease of movement.
Durability and Pricing
Durability Comparison
Durability is a key consideration for businesses operating in demanding environments:
- Honeywell Voyager 1200g:
- Drop-resistant housing up to 1.5 meters.
- Scratch-resistant window protects against daily wear and tear.
- Extended operating temperature range of -22°F to 122°F, suitable for cold environments like freezers.
- Symbol LS2208:
- Impact-resistant housing withstands drops from 1.2 meters.
- Sealed design protects against dust and water ingress.
- Operating temperature range of 32°F to 122°F, limiting use in extremely cold settings.
The Voyager 1200g's superior durability features make it a better choice for industries such as manufacturing and warehousing, where equipment is subjected to harsh conditions. The LS2208, while durable, is more suited for retail and office environments with less extreme conditions.
Pricing Comparison
Budget constraints are a significant factor in selecting barcode scanners:
- Honeywell Voyager 1200g: Approximately $150, reflecting its advanced features and higher durability.
- Symbol LS2208: Around $90, offering a cost-effective solution without sacrificing essential functionality.
While the Voyager 1200g commands a higher price, its enhanced performance and durability may justify the investment for businesses with intensive scanning needs. Conversely, the LS2208 provides excellent value for smaller businesses or those with moderate scanning requirements.
Additionally, the Voyager 1200g comes with a 5-year warranty, compared to the LS2208's 3-year warranty, offering extended peace of mind for long-term usage.
Pros and Cons
Honeywell Voyager 1200g
Pros:
- High accuracy and speed
- Comfortable grip design
- Versatile scanning capabilities
- Durable and long-lasting, reducing the need for frequent replacements
- Compatible with a wide range of operating systems and software
Cons:
- Higher price point
- May be excessive for businesses with smaller scanning needs
- Not suitable for scanning barcodes with low contrast or damage
- Requires regular maintenance and cleaning to ensure optimal performance
Symbol LS2208 by Zebra
Pros:
- Affordable option for businesses with smaller scanning needs
- Lightweight and ergonomic design
- Durable construction
- Wide scan angle for efficient high-volume scanning
Cons:
- May lack some advanced features found in higher-end scanners
- Lower accuracy levels compared to more sophisticated models
- Limited performance in extreme environmental conditions
User Reviews and Applications
User Reviews
User feedback highlights the strengths and weaknesses of both scanners:
- Honeywell Voyager 1200g: Users praise its high-quality construction, fast and accurate scanning, and robust performance in demanding environments. Many appreciate the ergonomic design and long battery life, which enhance productivity.
- Symbol LS2208: Reviewers commend its affordability, ease of use, and reliability. Its lightweight design is frequently mentioned as a positive, making it suitable for extended use without causing fatigue. Some users, however, note that it lacks advanced features found in more expensive models.
Overall, both scanners receive high marks for their respective strengths, with the Voyager 1200g favored for heavyweight industrial use and the LS2208 preferred for cost-effective, everyday scanning tasks.
Applications
Both scanners are versatile and find applications across various industries:
- Retail: Efficient inventory management and point-of-sale transactions.
- Logistics: Streamlining warehouse operations and shipment tracking.
- Healthcare: Managing patient records and medication inventories.
- Manufacturing: Quality control and tracking components through production lines.
- Hospitality: Managing reservations and inventory in restaurants and hotels.
The Honeywell Voyager 1200g is ideal for environments requiring rapid and precise scanning, such as large warehouses and busy retail settings. The Symbol LS2208, with its affordable price and reliable performance, is perfect for smaller businesses or applications where portability and ease of use are paramount.
Which Barcode Scanner is Best for Your Business?
The optimal choice between the Honeywell Voyager 1200g and the Symbol LS2208 depends on several factors:
- Business Size: Larger businesses with high scanning volumes may benefit more from the Voyager 1200g's advanced features.
- Budget: Businesses with tighter budgets might prefer the cost-effective Symbol LS2208.
- Scanning Needs: If your operations require scanning in rugged environments or handling a variety of barcode types, the Voyager 1200g is preferable.
- Portability: For businesses needing lightweight and easily maneuverable scanners, the LS2208 is advantageous.
Assessing your specific requirements in these areas will guide you to the scanner that best aligns with your business objectives.
Conclusion: Choosing Between the Honeywell Voyager 1200g and the Symbol LS2208 by Zebra
Both the Honeywell Voyager 1200g and the Symbol LS2208 by Zebra are exceptional barcode scanners, each offering a range of features tailored to different business needs. The Voyager 1200g stands out with its advanced scanning technology, superior durability, and extended warranty, making it a worthy investment for businesses demanding high performance and reliability. On the other hand, the Symbol LS2208 provides a balance of affordability and functionality, making it ideal for smaller operations or those seeking a cost-effective scanning solution.
Consider factors such as your business size, budget, scanning requirements, and the operating environment when making your decision. By evaluating these aspects, you can select the barcode scanner that will best enhance your business operations and efficiency.
