Zebra DS2208 Vs Honeywell Granit 1911i

When it comes to mobile scanning solutions, Zebra and Honeywell have been two of the most reputable names in the market for years. Both brands offer a diverse range of products, but in this article, we'll focus on comparing their handheld scanners: the Zebra DS2208 and the Honeywell Granit 1911i.

Introducing the Zebra DS2208 and Honeywell Granit 1911i

The Zebra DS2208 and the Honeywell Granit 1911i are both handheld barcode scanners engineered to deliver fast and accurate scanning across various settings. These scanners are integral to multiple industries, including retail, healthcare, logistics, and manufacturing.

The Zebra DS2208 is a lightweight and compact scanner tailored for retail environments. It efficiently scans both 1D and 2D barcodes, enhancing its versatility. Featuring a bright LED aimer, the DS2208 ensures precise aiming even in low-light conditions, which is crucial in bustling retail spaces.

Conversely, the Honeywell Granit 1911i is designed for durability in harsh environments. Built to endure drops, shocks, dust, and water exposure, it's perfect for warehouses and manufacturing plants. Additionally, it boasts a long-range scanning capability, allowing users to scan barcodes from distances up to 50 feet.

Physical Comparison: Size, Weight, and Appearance

The Zebra DS2208 and Honeywell Granit 1911i differ significantly in design, each offering unique benefits. The DS2208 is notably compact, measuring 6.5 x 2.6 x 3.9 inches and weighing just 5.9 ounces, making it easily pocketable. In contrast, the Granit 1911i is larger, with dimensions of 7.5 x 2.8 x 5.2 inches and a weight of 13.6 ounces, reflecting its rugged build.

Despite these differences, both scanners deliver impressive scanning capabilities. The DS2208 can read barcodes from up to 25 inches away, while the Granit 1911i extends this range to nearly 30 inches. Furthermore, the Granit 1911i excels in reading damaged or poorly printed barcodes, a critical feature in industrial settings where barcode quality may be compromised.

In terms of connectivity, the DS2208 offers USB, Bluetooth, and NFC options. The Granit 1911i, however, expands its connectivity with USB, Bluetooth, and Wi-Fi, providing greater flexibility in large-scale operations like warehouses and distribution centers.

Performance Comparison: Scanning Speed, Accuracy, and Range

Performance is a key factor in the effectiveness of handheld scanners. The DS2208 is renowned for its high accuracy and rapid scanning speed, capable of 240 scans per second from up to 24 inches away. This makes it ideal for fast-paced retail environments where speed and precision are paramount.

On the other hand, the Granit 1911i shines in environments requiring extended range and durability. With a scanning range of up to 50 feet and a speed of 50 scans per second, it is well-suited for large warehouses and factories. Its ability to accurately read barcodes even under challenging conditions ensures minimal downtime and increased productivity.

Durability is another critical aspect. The DS2208 is built to withstand drops from up to 5 feet, making it reliable for everyday use in retail. The Granit 1911i surpasses this with an IP65 rating, providing protection against dust and water, and can endure drops from up to 6.5 feet, ensuring longevity in the most demanding environments.

Connectivity Comparison: Wired and Wireless Options

Connectivity options are essential for integrating scanners into existing systems. Both scanners support USB connections, but they differ in their wireless capabilities. The DS2208 includes USB, Bluetooth, and NFC, while the Granit 1911i offers USB, Bluetooth, and Wi-Fi connectivity.

The inclusion of Wi-Fi in the Granit 1911i provides enhanced flexibility, especially in expansive facilities where wireless connectivity can streamline operations. However, wireless connections can be susceptible to issues like interference and battery limitations. In contrast, the DS2208's Bluetooth and NFC offer reliable wireless options, complemented by the stability of wired USB connections.

Choosing between wired and wireless connectivity should be based on your business's specific needs. Environments requiring uninterrupted, stable connections might benefit more from wired options, while those needing mobility and flexibility may prefer wireless connectivity.

Battery Life Comparison: How Long Can They Last?

Battery longevity is crucial for uninterrupted operations. The Zebra DS2208 is equipped with a rechargeable Lithium-Ion battery that offers up to 14 hours of usage on a single charge, depending on usage patterns. Similarly, the Honeywell Granit 1911i features a removable Lithium-Ion battery lasting up to 14 hours, with the option to extend battery life using an additional power pack available for purchase separately.

Environmental factors can influence battery performance. Extreme temperatures and high usage of features like Bluetooth can reduce battery life. It's also important to consider charging times: the DS2208 charges fully in approximately 2.5 hours, while the Granit 1911i takes about 4 hours to fully charge. Planning for charging cycles ensures that your scanners remain operational throughout the workday.

Durability Comparison: Which Scanner Can Withstand Harsh Environments?

Durability is a critical factor, especially in industrial settings. While both the Zebra DS2208 and Honeywell Granit 1911i are built to be rugged, the Granit 1911i offers superior durability. It can withstand multiple drops from 6 feet and holds an IP65 rating for dust and water resistance, making it ideal for harsh environments.

The DS2208, although durable enough for busy retail environments with drop resistance up to 5 feet, does not match the Granit 1911i's level of protection. Additionally, the Granit 1911i's extended battery life and long-range scanning capabilities make it a more robust option for settings that require reliable performance over prolonged periods.

Moreover, the ability of the Granit 1911i to scan barcodes from distances up to 50 feet is particularly beneficial in large warehouses or manufacturing floors with high shelving and expansive layouts.

Pricing Comparison: Which Scanner Offers Better Value for Money?

Price is often a determining factor in choosing the right scanner. The Zebra DS2208 is more budget-friendly, starting at around $170, making it an excellent choice for small to medium-sized businesses seeking reliability without a hefty investment.

In contrast, the Honeywell Granit 1911i is priced higher, typically upwards of $700. This higher cost reflects its enhanced durability, extended battery life, and advanced scanning capabilities. For businesses operating in demanding environments where longevity and performance are critical, the Granit 1911i offers better long-term value despite the initial investment.

Additionally, the Granit 1911i comes with a three-year warranty, compared to the DS2208's one-year warranty. This extended warranty period can provide added peace of mind and reduce long-term maintenance costs.

When evaluating value for money, consider not only the upfront cost but also the total cost of ownership, including durability, warranty, and the potential need for replacements or repairs.

User-Friendliness Comparison: Ease of Use and Set-Up Process

User experience is crucial for efficient operations. Both scanners are designed with user-friendliness in mind, featuring intuitive interfaces and straightforward setup processes. However, there are notable differences between the two.

The Zebra DS2208 boasts a simple button layout, making it easy to navigate and operate, even for users with minimal technical expertise. Its plug-and-play nature means it requires no additional software or drivers, allowing for quick deployment.

On the other hand, the Honeywell Granit 1911i has a more complex interface with additional buttons and configurable options. While this complexity allows for greater customization and control, it may require more training and a longer setup period.

Ultimately, the DS2208 is ideal for businesses that need a straightforward, easy-to-use scanner, whereas the Granit 1911i is better suited for environments where customization and advanced features are necessary.

Industry-Specific Applications: Which Scanner is Best Suited for Your Business Needs?

Choosing the right scanner depends on your industry's specific requirements:

Retail, Healthcare, Hospitality: The Zebra DS2208 is optimal due to its affordability, ease of use, and reliable performance in environments where speed and accuracy are essential.
Manufacturing, Logistics, Warehousing: The Honeywell Granit 1911i excels with its rugged design, extended scanning range, and durability, making it ideal for demanding settings where equipment is subject to harsh conditions.

Customer Reviews: What Are Users Saying About the Zebra DS2208 and Honeywell Granit 1911i?

User feedback for both scanners has been overwhelmingly positive, highlighting their respective strengths:

Zebra DS2208: Users commend its accuracy, speed, and cost-effectiveness. It's praised for seamless integration into retail systems and its lightweight design, which reduces user fatigue.
Honeywell Granit 1911i: Reviews highlight its exceptional durability and versatile scanning capabilities. Users appreciate its ability to function reliably in challenging environments and its extended battery life.

However, some users find the Granit 1911i's setup process more complex compared to the DS2208, requiring additional time and technical know-how.

Conclusion: Which Scanner Should You Choose?

Both the Zebra DS2208 and Honeywell Granit 1911i are outstanding handheld barcode scanners, each catering to different needs:

Zebra DS2208: Ideal for businesses seeking an affordable, reliable scanner for general use, particularly in retail, healthcare, and hospitality industries.
Honeywell Granit 1911i: Best suited for environments that demand ruggedness and durability, such as manufacturing, logistics, and warehousing.

Your choice should be guided by your specific operational requirements, budget, and the environment in which the scanner will be used. Both Zebra and Honeywell have a proven track record for quality and durability, ensuring that whichever scanner you choose will meet your business's scanning needs effectively.